This might be a good place to start for those of you who don't have much personal experience with AA:
http://www.blinkx.com/watch-video/penn-teller-bullshit-12-stepping/_R4YPBfLS7sXY1H_F8dmLA
My friend posted this on facebook. She is one of my personal heroes, having quit drinking without any of the AA bullshit.
If you think I am being a bit extreme here, please hear me out. I'm not even that interested in discussing the groups merits at large. I think Penn&Teller do a fine job of that in their manner. This is meant to be a personal testimony, so yeah... it's all about me. What follows may not be representative of most AA children, it might not even hold true for my siblings, but I have a hard time believing I am alone in this.
AA has a pervasive quality to it. Even when my parents were around the language they speak with, especially my mother who has bought into the program more thoroughly, is decidedly AA. If my mom ever gives me advice, then it comes from something she has learned at her meetings. But fine, if they want to be brainwashed or even feel like they need to be brainwashed fine. However, I think it severely stunted them at parents. In fact despite the fundamental problems of my early childhood, I think what came later was more damaging by far.
By making AA a cult, by taking away personal decision, I think AA falls short in one obvious and thorough way. I think they don't treat the problem, rather they focus strictly on wiping away the symptoms. Or rather they think they are treating the problem by turning it over to "a higher power" to treat it for them, which is again bullshit.
My mom, and to a certain degree myself, we get addicted to things. My mom has been addicted to lemons, bridge mix, alcohol, other people, movies, certain restaurants, you name it. If you have ever wondered where I get it... The point is, I think it would have helped her more to confront the reasons why she gets addicted, what she is trying to replace, and how to get the real thing rather than a replacement. What I think she is looking for, of course, is simple. Support and then Power. But that has more to do with me and my own beliefs.
You may notice at this point, if you know me well, that my points aren't coming out as clearly or passionately as I'd like. I should tell you this is probably among the 5 toughest blog posts I have ever written. Probably among the 5 toughest things I have ever tried to say in any form. There is a toad in my throat, and my eyes are stinging and wet. But I think this is important. I think it is important to admit to myself, and you, how deep this goes for me.
When I was young, I wet the bed. It was my mother who told me I was making the decision to wet my bed, and she wouldn't continue to support that decision by giving me attention of any kind when it happened. Fine. Okay. But then she would turn around and drive to her meeting the next morning and claim that she couldn't decide whether or not to drink certain substances.
We listened to her cult-speak all through childhood, and yet guess what we all three were doing last St.Pat's Day? That's right, drinking together.
After my mom got really into AA, we really didn't have a mother. We had a crying two year old brat who got addicted to anything that could replace alcohol and yet fall under the heading of "harmless". She got really overweight, so then she had to do OA as well. These meetings, the friends made there, and the people who she "sponsored" were her real children. Everything she said to me was rehearsed. She was literally gone most days and evenings, and when she was home she was on the phone.
Then she even forced us to start going to meetings while she went to meetings. We were the only children there who did not actually remember seeing their parents ever drink. My brother was young enough and imaginative enough that he made up stories about my mom, and my sister and I were regarded as "being in denial".
Again when I was older she would try to coax me into going to meetings with the incentive of lunch afterward. Because alcoholism is a hereditary disease, it was possible for me to have it even if I never touched a drop. When I slapped a girl in high school, part of my punishment was to go to a few meetings.
I do believe alcoholism is a "hereditary disease" if by "hereditary disease" you mean that certain harmful patterns of behavior are environmentally shoved into the next generation. I mean, I looked up to my mom as many children do. I learned from her how to deal with life and make friends and deal with my own mistakes and how to act when something went wrong.
What I am saying amounts to this: The same harmful family cycles that have been recorded in alcoholic families continued in my family despite the absence of any alcohol.
Oh. And meetings were so addictive to my mom that it was considered perfectly rational if she were a complete bitch because she missed a day.
Now my dad, who resisted for many years, has become a full-fledged underling of the cult. That's right, my never-alcoholic-dad who would hardly sip at wine is now an active member of AA. And you know what he says about it?
He says it is great when you are filled with so much guilt and uncertainty to go to a group and listen to stories and realize that everybody has made the same stupid mistakes and worse mistakes even. In other words, if you feel really guilty it feels good to know that lots of other people feel really guilty. Then you can all sit a room and feel guilty, and then you can write down everything you feel guilty for and to whom, and then you can go out and "make amends" and then you can come back the next day and have another guilt-fest. Guilt with a tasty side of guilt. Fuck that shit.
The ironic thing is that my parents' basic philosophies have always been and still are existentialist. And yet they don't recognize it as such, and don't see how everything they have professed to believing directly opposes the brainwashed AA jargon they spew. They don't take responsibility for their own behavior, though from a very young age they have expected us to take full responsibility for any and all of our actions.
So my mom may no longer be an alcoholic, though of course she still says she is, but everything she does she does as an alcoholic, an addict, a person who does not notice how destructive her approach to others and to activities really is. Because, AA is not about overcoming behavioral patterns, no matter how much my mom tries to convince me that they are.
They give some people, the few people who have success with them, exactly what their addict-addicted minds want. They give them something new to obsess over, to focus their lives around, to get addicted to. They tell them it's not their fault, and therefore not a part of their overall life patterns and choices, that they get addicted to things.
In fact, they even give them some of the things they were most trying to replace with their addictions. Social acceptance, attention, power within the group, a distraction, an attraction, a feeling like they aren't alone, something worth living for. All good things, no? I would say no, because all of these good things only exist within the group, they need to continue in the group to continue to have these things, once outside they are a nobody again. They don't have time, and aren't taught how, and are taught that it is in fact not necessary, to get what they really needed all along in their lives at large and in general.
Most damning of all they suggest a new addiction to a "Higher Power". A higher power that at the same time as obviously being equated with God, is brought to the people through "the big book" which replaces or grows equal with the Bible. Such that even when I was a Christian I believed the whole practice to be actually a form of idol-worship.
Oh. And then the money and resources in addition to the time they have wasted on this program are astounding. It isn't okay to go on family vacations, money is an object the whole time if we do, but it's okay to spend money on "retreats". To pay money to go out into a beautiful wilderness and get brainwashed some more, when going out with the family to the wilderness would be essentially free.
So no. I am not going to admit to being an addict of any sort, but I will admit freely that I participate in some obsessively recurring behaviors. These unhealthy behaviors, it is my first goal to figure out where I am participating in them and my second goal to stop these behaviors or more specifically replace them with healthy behaviors.
I know my grammar was worse in this post than most. And I know I did not even succeed in my usual lyricism or passion. But this post was like therapy for me, a really rigorous therapy resonating deep into my wounds.